Topics covered

Reviewed AC framework structure and value/criterion relationship — focused on tightening the internal link between the standard and the value to eliminate judge skepticism. Drilled 1AR time allocation strategy on theory and substantive responses, emphasizing collapsing early rather than spreading thin. Worked through NR block strategy on contentions, identifying which extensions require impact calculus vs. which can be dropped strategically. Discussed transition from circuit to local judging paradigms and how to adjust delivery and framing accordingly.

Comments

Shyla had a strong session today — showed noticeable improvement in her ability to identify which arguments are load-bearing vs. which are filler. Her 1AR instincts are developing well; she's learning to trust strategic concessions rather than feeling like she has to answer everything. Main area for continued work is confident delivery on the rebuttal overview — the analysis is there but needs to come out with more conviction. Recommended she flow two practice rounds this week before the next session and focus specifically on how top debaters frame extinction-level impacts in the 2NR. Overall a productive hour.